Make values a part of firm

08/04/02
Brigham Young University
By By Craig Earnshaw
Printed in the Deseret News

      When I was younger and about to leave the house, my mother would often say: "Remember who you are." That advice was a reminder of my values and a warning against straying from my goals. Those words provide powerful business advice as well.

To remember who we are, we must first know who we are and what our business is. For many, the business just evolves into its present state over time. But a wise business owner will decide what his business is, and what it will be. Having made that decision, he is much more likely to be successful.

The fundamental decision each business owner must make is to select his value proposition. The value proposition is the core offering of the company, the dimension that distinguishes it from the competition. It is the concept for which the company is known and upon which its reputation is built. Having selected a value proposition, the company can focus its efforts on that concept and concentrate on delivering greater value to its customers year after year.

In the excellent book "The Discipline of Market Leaders," by Michael Treacy and Fred Wiersema, the authors identify three value propositions: operational excellence, product leadership and customer intimacy. Let's take a closer look at these three value propositions.

Operational excellence means low prices and hassle-free service. Operationally, excellent companies offer a combination of quality, price and ease of purchase that no competitor can match. These companies are not innovators, nor do they cultivate customer relationships. Market leaders in this area include Wal-Mart, Dell Computers and Southwest Airlines.

Product leadership means offering the best product. Product leaders constantly innovate and offer products that push performance boundaries. They work to make their own products obsolete and replace them with a new generation. Market leaders in this area include Intel and Nokia.

      Customer intimacy means a superior customer experience. Customer-intimate companies concentrate not on what the market wants but on what specific customers want. They do not pursue transactions, they cultivate relationships. Market leaders in this area include Nordstrom, Airborne Express and the Four Seasons.

Each business owner should examine these three value propositions carefully and ask himself: "How do we compete and win in our marketplace?" He should then select his value proposition and construct his operational model and plans around it. By excelling at the selected value proposition, his company ceases to resemble its competitors and moves to a position of market leadership.

After examining the three value propositions, many will say, "But we try to excel in all of these areas." Selecting one value proposition does not mean that a company can neglect the other two. On the contrary, it must maintain threshold standards in the other areas. A product leader may command higher prices, but prices must still be reasonable. An operationally excellent company must earn repeat business by treating its customers well even while charging the lowest prices.

There is great power in knowing who we are. It helps to define the business and its method of operation. Then, as we remember who we are, the business can focus on the things that matter most.

author1 is associated with the BYU Center for Entrepreneurship. He can be reached via e-mail at Mr. Williams is associated with the BYU Center for Entrepreneurship. He can be reached via e-mail at cfe@byu.edu. .