Righting troubles pays off

07/07/02
Brigham Young University
By By Eric Farr Printed in the Deseret News
      When I was attending BYU, one of my favorite professors told our class about an experience he once had at a local dry cleaner. He felt that he had been treated unfairly, and since the store owner did not rectify the problem, he promised never to return. Little did the store owner know, however, that for the next 15 or more years before he retired as a professor, he would tell every class he taught about his bad experience at the dry cleaner. I figure that he may have encouraged as many as 6,000 students to avoid that particular cleaner!
      A good friend of mine, Paul Timm, wrote about the costs associated with losing an unhappy customer in his book, "Customer Service: Career Success Through Customer Satisfaction." Paul explains that the average unhappy customer will tell 10 to 20 people about his or her unpleasant experience. Even more alarming is that those people will then typically tell an additional five people each. So if all 6,000 people relayed the professor's story to five people, then 30,000 people have heard about a poor experience with this certain dry cleaner.
      For argument's sake, however, let's assume a typical example whereby one unhappy customer tells 10 people, who then each tell five others. That is a total of 51 people who are now a part of this bad experience with the dry cleaner.
      What financial impact does this have on the store owner? Let's assume that the experience is bad enough that 25 percent, or 13 of the 51 people, actually stop using that particular dry cleaner. If the average person spends $20 a month on dry cleaning, then the cleaner has lost revenues of $260 per month, or $3,120 annually.
      Paul also discusses in his book that it typically costs about five times as much to attract a new customer as it does to retain a current customer. How much do you think it would have cost the store owner to resolve the problem with the professor? Maybe $20 or $25 in free dry cleaning? It might cost the storeowner $100 in advertising, promotional and sales expenses to attract a new customer. Therefore, to attract new customers to fill the void of the 13 who left would cost $1,300. Remember, that cost is in addition to the $3,120 of lost revenue, and all of it could have been avoided by a mere $20 gift.
      Too often business owners don't think about the long-term impact of an unhappy customer. As our example shows, it is much more expensive to allow a customer to be unhappy than it is to quickly resolve the issue.
      Because customers expect things to go wrong occasionally, having an unhappy customer can be an opportunity to create a loyal customer. Think about when you have been unhappy with a company but something was done to immediately rectify the problem. If I had to guess, you are still doing business with that company because it is willing to resolve problems that may arise. You probably even told people about the good experience you had with that particular company.
      I encourage you to run a similar exercise that is specific to your business. I am confident you will find that the happiness of your customers can be critical to your bottom line. Once you realize this, you may look at an unhappy customer in a whole new way.
      By the way, if my professor's experience was heard by 30,000 people and only 1 percent decided not to use the cleaner, then lost revenue could now be as high as $72,000 a year. In this case, the businessman is clearly taking himself to the cleaners.

author1 is associated with the BYU Center for Entrepreneurship. He can be reached via e-mail at Mr. Williams is associated with the BYU Center for Entrepreneurship. He can be reached via e-mail at cfe@byu.edu. .