|
There are many reasons why the United States has been a fertile field for entrepreneurs:
flexible capital markets, a culture that supports taking risks and is accepting of failure, and a regulatory system that
is less oppressive than most countries.
However, there is one area in which the United States is much worse than other countries
in ways that discourage and destroy many new ideas and businesses: litigation.
In a recent book, "The Rule of Lawyers," Walter Olson details some of the worst abuses.
He reviews the billions of dollars that flow from businesses into lawyers' pockets and how
little may actually make it to "victims." He cites several examples where lawyers in class-action suits were paid millions
of dollars and the "victims" received no compensation.
There are examples in which the business won its case and was proved innocent but went into
bankruptcy due to the cost of defending itself. Unlike the English legal system, in which the loser must pay the winner's
costs, the United States allows lawyers to pursue even a preposterous case in which the lawyers may make millions if they
win, but lose only time if they lose.
Similarly, punitive damages can kill businesses and jobs. One business dispute cited in the
book had actual damages of $637.99, but the jury attached punitive damages of $36 million.
Olson also shares examples of judges who are elected to their positions and whose political
campaigns receive sizable contributions from the very attorneys whose cases they will hear. In some locations, lawyers
account for more than 75 percent of campaign donations.
Lawyers often select sites for trial that have a history of awarding enormous damages to
plaintiffs. Fayette, Miss., has a population of 8,385, but since 1995 more than 21,000 persons have filed lawsuits there,
most claiming injury from prescription drugs or asbestos.
|