|
It started out like many phone calls
I get.
"Hey Steve, I have this brilliant business
idea I would like to discuss with you. Can we get together today?"
the caller asked, almost pleading.
As we talked on the phone, I learned
that he had a possibly viable idea for joining two huge industries
together with a technical product that would solve a distribution
problem that was plaguing both of them. We arranged for a speedy
lunch at my favorite sandwich shop, where on a yellow pad, Jason
(not his real name) diagramed a technical product that could be
marketed from kiosks in airports throughout the world. I was convinced
that if the product could be produced, it could solve a big problem
for two industries. And as a business opportunity, it had the potential
to be huge -- maybe a $150 million per year deal.
But here's the rub. Does Jason have
the skills, resources and tenacity to pull off his groundbreaking,
revolutionary idea? No! Does he have the technical ability to produce
the product? No! Does he have sufficient contacts he can trust who
can plug in the missing pieces? No! Can he adequately protect his
idea through patents to prevent his idea from being stolen by the
"big boys" with the problem? I doubt it.
Then is his idea an opportunity worth
pursuing? I think not. It is a classic example of the difference
between an idea (of which there is an abundance) and an opportunity
worth pursuing (of which there is a shortage).
Jason has a great idea, and it could
be the opportunity of a lifetime. But let's look at his situation.
His research shows that his idea, with proper diagrams and technical
data, is patentable; however, the patent will cost $20,000. And
that presents his first problem: he doesn't have the money. Like
many idea people, he has the idea but not a job or any serious savings.
Secondly, if he had the $20,000 or could
raise it, is it a good idea to get the patent? What if he gets the
patent and someone -- someone big -- likes the idea from studying
the patent and begins producing the product. What is Jason going
to do -- sue? Where is he going to get the money to do that? Is
getting the patent a good way for protection or a vehicle to spread
the word about the concept and let someone else steal the idea?
|